Header-lansing_1.jpg
 
Home News  Race and sidewalks
. . . . . .
Friday, January 7,2011

Race and sidewalks

Clergy, Mayor Bernero want an apology from Bill Ballenger for his comments in the Waverly Road sidewalk flap

by Andy Balaskovitz
Friday, Jan. 7 — The Clergy Forum of Greater Lansing, a group of black pastors, called today for a boycott of political analyst Bill Ballenger’s services over his “elitist, sexist and racist statements made in City Pulse” regarding a proposed sidewalk along Waverly Road.

“We are calling for Bill Ballenger to publicly apologize to the community and for those who employ his services to cease and desist,” Melvin T. Jones, president of the Clergy Forum, said today at a press conference.

Lansing City Councilman Derrick Quinney attended the press conference and expressed his support for the Clergy Forum’s position.

Lansing Mayor Virg Bernero also issued a similar statement.

“His words reflect a gross intolerance and contempt for Lansing’s diversity and reveal his true motives in opposing a project that will make major safety improvements for citizens who walk in that area,” the mayor’s statement says. “I also believe Mr. Ballenger should relinquish his position on WKAR-TV’s ‘Off the Record’ show.”

Ballenger was quoted in Wednesday’s City Pulse as saying that the foot path that exists now — which a sidewalk would replace — serves “mostly power-walking women from Moores Park” and “foot traffic from Jolly Road that is mostly lower income, largely African American.” He also called the $1.3 million price tag for the proposed Lansing and Lansing Township sidewalk “insane.”

“What I told you wasn’t racist,” Ballenger said today. “You mangled what I said. You took two quotes out of context.”

“The fact of the matter is that most of the people who actually use it now are lower income from Jolly Road,” he added. “I see them all. You can tell from their clothing that they’re not affluent people.”

He said he is not opposed to the project because of who uses the path. “If I had that much of a problem I would have said something a long time ago.” He said he opposes spending $1.3 million on a sidewalk that he expects will be underused.

"That's why he (Bernero) wants to build this. They want a path to the YMCA. They want an antiseptic environment paved in gold,” Ballenger said.

Ballenger does not dispute he made the comments attributed to him. He said he can see who uses the path from inside his house.

“The fact is there are hardly any people using the sidewalk. You saw for yourself” Ballenger said.

Ballenger, 69, lives at 2029 S. Waverly Road, in the Waverly Hills subdivision. He is a former Republican state representative and state senator, an ex-state racing commissioner, and director of the Michigan Department of Licensing & Regulation. Ballenger also served as deputy assistant secretary of the U.S. Department of Health, Education & Welfare in the administration of President Gerald R. Ford.

He is the editor and owner of the newsletter Inside Michigan Politics and a commentator on local television and radio. He also speaks to local organizations and businesses.

Ballenger said there is nothing to apologize for, not even for generalizing the socioeconomic status and race of those who use the narrow footpath near his home.

“My next-door neighbor is African American, and we stand shoulder to shoulder on this (sidewalk) issue,” Ballenger said.


Share
 
 


  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 
As you know, I am not one to reflexively cry "racism" for every slight, real or imagined. In this case, I would say that the Lansing pastors and Bernero clearly have a valid point. As Biddle correctly noted, why mention race at all if one's opposition is merely financial? My impression is that the neighborhood's opposition to this sidewalk is deeply rooted in racism, classism, and a sense of exclusivist entitlement.
abc
Welcome to our coach outlet .Coach as a main competitor in coach factory outlet.Creation from fashion brands to the portal based around coach bags,Coach Outlet in terms of production quality and fabrics are under a lot of effort.Coach bags as a major flagship brand products,not only versatile color,but also with coach outlet stores to spend a lot of coach boots.Like Coach Poppy Bags series,not only a variety of styles,but also so many lovely girls embarked on a fashion line.coach handbags not only opened the door of fashion,it is convenient for the masses of the road.
 
The only question I have is why even bring up the race, gender, and stereotypes he did when discussing the project? What relevance did they have to his opposition of the project if not for the fact for their racial and sexist undertones? What is even the point of bringing up that he thinks the people he sees come down from Jolly Road? Are they somehow less entitled to something as basic as a sidewalk on a very busy road because of where they come from? Are they less deserving of patronizing the businesses along Waverly and the YMCA along these roads because they don't have any other option but walking? Bill's words weren't taken out of context. This was not a gaffe. A gaffe is a mistake, a simple mix-up of words or terms. Bill said what he meant to say (which is why he's not apologizing for it); Bill revealed to us his worldview, a worldview in which people should "know their place" and where pedestrians are second-class citizens, particularly ones who are not of his sex or race or lifestyle. Don't be mad at Bill, pity him.
 
 
 
 
Search Archive
Search Archive:
 
 

© 2013 City Pulse

City Pulse. 2001 E. Michigan Ave. Lansing, MI 48912.
Phone: (517)371-5600. Fax: (517) 999-6066.
E-mail: publisher@lansingcitypulse.com

 
Close