against ‘manure madness’ in central Michigan escalates
There’s a big yellow smiley face painted on the barn of Lynn Henning’s
farm, just outside of Clayton, Mich., about 60 miles south of Lansing.
The smile lets visitors know that the 45-year-old crop farmer hasn’t
given in yet. It was three year ago that Henning began a battle against
the factory farms that had begun arriving in Lenawee and Hillsdale counties
in the early 1990s. She and a group of other concerned citizens documented
the unbearable stench and monitored the water pollution that stemmed
from the 10 facilities, which had transformed both their communities
and the region.
henning holds a water sample from the south branch of the River
Raisin. Behind her is a barn at Baker Lads Farms, a CAFO in Clayton,
Mich. Over Henning’s shoulder is her water sample pole.
largest dairy farm operation, the Dutch-American company Vreba-Hoff
Dairy, LLC, is being sued by the Granholm administration for polluting
The 6,000 dairy cows from two south-central Michigan Vreba-Hoff operations
generate 120,000 gallons of manure each day. In September the Michigan
Department of Environmental Quality issued a civil lawsuit against Vreba-Hoff
Dairy in the 30th Judicial Circuit in Ingham County for the unlawful
discharge of agricultural wastes from two facilities, into state-owned
The Environmental Concerned Citizens of South Central Michigan, a group
of 20 small-scale farmers and area residents who felt threatened by
water and air pollution stemming from area factory farms have documented
50 cases of illegal discharges and reported them to MDEQ.
“While Michigan rightly prides itself on a rich agricultural heritage,
operations such as these that flout the law and pose an environmental
threat to the waters of this state give all of agriculture a black-eye,”
wrote DEQ’s new director, Steven E. Chester, in a press release.
“The citizens of this state should not be subjected to the pollution
generated by factory farms, and the DEQ will do what’s necessary
to pursue these violators.”
Sept. 3 cover story in City Pulse, “Manure Madness,”
reported on so-called factory farms in south-central Michigan. The
story, by freelance writer Emily Friedman, reported on environmental
problems caused by the disposal of cow manure. Soon after, City
Pulse received complaints about the story’s accuracy from
both its main source, Lynn Henning, and a representative of the
Michigan Farm Bureau, the state’s largest general farm organization.
City Pulse assigned staff writer Daniel Sturm to look into the story
anew. Sturm found the thrust of the story was accurate, as the accompanying
story shows. However, he also found the original story contained
a number of errors, which are corrected below. City Pulse apologizes:
1. “[Cow manure] is pouring into wells where
water will be drunk and next to the front steps of houses where
Hudson area environmentalists have found four water wells that
tested positive for coliform. The Escherichia coli bacteria levels
returned to normal before they were able to determine whether
factory farms, or human feces, were the cause.
2. “[Lynn Henning] works with government agencies like the
Michigan Department of Environmental Quality to prosecute those
who have violated federal and state law.”
The DEQ investigation of Vreba-Hoff was triggered by the data
gathered by volunteers last spring. Henning is a volunteer, and
doesn’t prosecute factory farms.
3. “The city sewer system is hooked up to the facility.”
Field tiles are placed under the soil to remove excess surface
water. When manure is applied to a field, it seeps through cracks
down to the field tile, from where it drains into ditches, streams,
or lakes. Henning made a comparison of field tiles to a city sewer
system, to illustrate the complex issue “for city folks.”
4. “A nearby nature preserve called Toad Creek has been
Toad Creek was polluted, but not destroyed. In November 2002,
the number of E. coli bacteria in Toad Creek was measured at 297,000
colonies per 100 milliliters - 297 times the legal maximum for
partial body contact.
5. “Someone has broken the pipe to drain more manure from
the field drains into the ditch to enter the water supply. It
looks as if someone has hacked it with an axe or some other sharp
In March 2003, DEQ found a Vreba-Hoff plugged field tile outlet
that was causing the liquids to purge through the ground surface
and flow across the field into South Medina Drain. The agency
cited Vreba-Hoff for multiple days of water quality violations.
6. “There has been a takeover of the rural community by
a corporate foreign cooperative bank in the Netherlands called
Rabobank International, which finances the farms,” Henning
Rabobank refinanced land for Vreba-Hoff. In addition to their
own two operations in Hudson, Vreba-Hoff has helped seven other
agricultural factories set up dairy operations in Michigan.
7. “Henning said that former Gov. John Engler did not enforce
laws to punish factory farms from the Netherlands because his
board invited them to Michigan.”
Michigan doesn’t “invite” factory farms, but
the CAFOs did receive government subsidies. In 1995–2002,
Vreba-Hoff co-owner Stephen Vanderhoff collected over $72,000
in dairy, corn, soybean and wheat subsidies.
8. “The cows were infected with tuberculosis and they were
still brought into the state.”
In 1998, the USDA suspended Michigan’s tuberculosis-free
status, after a cow in Alpena County tested positive. Of the 956,000
cattle tested as of March 2003, 68 have been identified as tuberculosis
infected. Several states now require testing of any livestock
prohibit any expansion of the operation until problems are resolved.
It’s also demanding that Vreba-Hoff construct a wastewater treatment
system, apply for a groundwater permit, and notify the state department
of any additional discharges. A fine up to $25,000 will be imposed for
each violation, and for each day of continued violation.
Vreba-Hoff is one of 10 “confined animal feeding operations”
(CAFOs) in the area, many of which confine thousands of cows, year-round.
These industrial farms use huge quantities of water to pump cow feces
into holding pits, some that are as large as lakes. Eventually the liquid
manure is sprayed onto fields.
Anne Woiwode, the director of the Sierra Club’s Mackinac Chapter,
said she’s pleasantly surprised about how far DEQ took this case.
“This lawsuit is precedent-setting,” she said. During the
winter 2002-‘03, just as Granholm’s administration was settling
in, the Hudson area’s 10 dairy operations were discharging record
levels of animal waste, Woiwode said.
The Sierra Club director called CAFO pollution in Hudson one of the
worst ecological disasters caused by factory farms in the country. “These
farms had too many facilities, too many animals, too little land, and
improper handling of the waste. And when there was a combination of
very cold winter weather and a sudden melt, this left waste all over
the place, and people were literary horrified.”
Vreba-Hoff spokeswoman Cecilia Conway admits that there have been six
incidences of “unplanned” manure discharges in the past,
but says they have gone to great length to prevent such discharges from
In addition to their own two operations in Hudson, the Dutch-American
CAFO has helped seven other agricultural factories set up dairy operations
in Michigan, including farms from Canada and the Netherlands.
Woiwode said that European and Canadian farmers were attracted by the
lax environmental regulations and the cheap land in the United States.
Factory farms began migrating into Hillsdale and Lenawee counties in
the late 1990s. Three years ago, when Vreba-Hoff Dairy built its second
operation, and environmentalists and area residents who felt their quality
of life was being endangered formed the Environmental Concerned Citizens
of South Central Michigan.
In 2001 the Sierra Club gave the group a $7,000 grant to pay for monitoring
expenses and assist with further training.
The team has a Web site, at nocafos.org, where they post their findings.
After one dumping, the environmental volunteers measured the number
of Escherichia coli bacteria in a county drain at 1.34 million colonies
per 100 milliliters—more than 1,000 times the Michigan water standard
for partial body contact.
Besides health concerns regarding water pollution, concerns also arise
from exposure to ammonia, methane gas, and hydrogen sulfide, emitted
from the dairy operations. Hydrogen sulfide, a gas which in low concentrations
smells like rotten eggs, and can cause not only flu-like symptoms, but
can also trigger anger attacks, and neuro-behavioral dysfunctions.
Henning, a co-founding group member and crop farmer, and her husband,
Dean, own 150 acres of farmland, which is literally surrounded by CAFOs.
Vreba-Hoff’s first factory farm is five miles away from their
property, and the American-owned 700-cow operation, Hartland Farms,
is just one mile away. Lynn Henning frequently suffers from dizziness
and burning eyes, and tends to have soar throats. She is also bothered
by the presence of swarms of flies on her property, which appeared together
with these operations.
Henning’s father-in-law, whose farmhouse is less than 100 feet
from Hartland Farms, suffers from hydrogen sulfide poisoning. The 82-year-old
farmer, Gerald Henning, and his wife, Cecilia, were diagnosed last April
by Kaye Kilburn, a professor of medicine at the University of Southern
California who is an expert on this type of poisoning.
Kilburn reported, “Both Henning’s show losses of functions
that are characteristic of brains damaged by hydrogen sulfide. They
are like workers exposed in oil or natural gas fields.”
For more than two years, Gerald Henning had called the state Department
of Agriculture hotline to complain about manure pollution near his farm,
a terrible smell, and a problem with flies. In an ironic twist, his
complaint finally drew public attention not because of the abnormal
level of pollution or the couple’s many health problems but because
Ingham County Prosecutor Stuart Dunnings evoked Michigan’s 19th
century obscenity law and sued the elderly farmer for cursing in a telephone
conversation with a public official.
Even though Lynn Henning’s group reported 26 illegal discharges
of manure to the Department of Environmental Quality between 2000 and
2002, under Gov. John Engler the department did not press any charges.
Michigan has no mandatory permit system, no inspection of lagoons, and
no requirements for manure management. Everything is voluntary. The
CAFOs did not even need building permits.
The Sierra Club increased its pressure on the Engler administration
by filing a petition with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,
asking Michigan’s authority to run the clean water program be
taken away. In 2001, Woiwode says, Michigan finally agreed to implement
federal water-discharge permit requirements—but only for CAFOs
that operate more than 714 dairy cows, and have already been found in
violation of the Clean Water Act.
Woiwode hopes the lawsuit against Vreba-Hoff will lead to long-term
policy changes. The Sierra Club has asked the new administration to
require smaller farms for a water permit and to regulate farms without
water violations. “We think all of these facilities should be
permitted in advance, before they ever have an animal occupy one of
their buildings,” Woiwode said. Agricultural operations should
be required to protect human health, just like any other industry. “If
you have a factory that is polluting, you can shut it down. This should
also apply to CAFOs.”
For Henning the battle against factory farms is not over. Although it
has already frosted several times this fall, her problem with flies
continues. In fact, the month of November appears to be one of the most
dangerous for water quality near factory farms, according to ECCSCM,
and this is what attracts the insects. After crops have been harvested,
there’s little vegetation on field surfaces, and when liquid manure
is applied in large quantities, it often reaches the underground drainage
tiles, which flow into nearby streams.
Reflecting on the state government’s lawsuit against Vreba-Hoff,
Henning said she thought it was sad to hear that Michigan had to press
charges to prevent a pollution problem. “After all, farmers are
supposed to be protecting their food, land, and water.” On the
other hand, Henning is very glad that someone in the state government
has finally decided to address the pollution of Michigan waters. “I
am a small family farmer, but I am representing the largest stakeholders
in Michigan, the people. We must stop the pollution and make everyone
accountable for their actions!”
to respond? Send letters to email@example.com.
our Letters policy.